A lot of the decision will be based on your current family needs. My kids are older so I don't need a massive amount of cargo room any more. If you have small kids with car seats and whatnot then an SUV may be the way to go. You can get a decently loaded forester (touring trim) for around the same as the Optima EX Luxury.... but here's what you get on the Optima you probably won't get on the forester:
- heated and cooled front seats
- heated rear seats
- 530 watt infinity stereo
- panoramic sunroof
- leather seats
- 18" tires
- voice command
- heated steering wheel
- 5 year bumper to bumper warranty
- better interest rate 0% vs 2.9%
- MUCH MORE FUN AND ENGAGING TO DRIVE
- a vehicle that is not very common yet
- about 20% better fuel economy
- A wicked looking ride
Here's what you get on the forester that's not on the optima:
- AWD
- More cargo space with all the seats down (the optima does have a large trunk though and folding rear seats)
- Way more boringness
If you need AWD then the Optima should be off your list, other than that it should be on it. I just plan on buying a good set of winter tires next year, I mean until 5 or 6 years ago most people drove cars as opposed to SUVs and they got along just fine. I would go 100% with the Optima over the Forester unless you have a couple of small kids. I will keep you updated on how the Optima holds up in the snow tomorrow! We are expecting 30cms!